As
a Cal State Northridge associate professor, Kenneth Ng spends his days
teaching students the principles of economics: markets, monetary policy,
interest rates.
But in his free time, Ng focuses on a very different kind of market:
sex tourism in Thailand. For the past year, Ng has been running a Web
site that offers insights into the Thai bar scene, such as where to meet
beautiful women and how to negotiate fees for their services.
But he was outed by a group of foreign businessmen who were outraged
by what they considered a disrespectful Internet posting. They contacted
his employer and colleagues, hoping Ng would be pressured into taking
down his site.
It was a post he wrote on another Web site, run by owners of the Big
Mango Bar in Bangkok, that triggered the organized campaign against him.
In it, he instructed men to look for women near a particular Buddhist
shrine. The Big Mango Bar owners said they found his post disrespectful.
University officials say they will not intervene or discipline Ng as
long as his extracurricular activities do not involve public resources.
...Read full
article
Update:
Self Censored Under Pressure
24th April 2010. See
article from
bigbabykenny.com
An
American professors website about Bangkok nightlife has been deleted bar
a final explanatory posting:
For those not familiar with Bangkok, many bars,
including the Big Mango Bar, are actually brothels. They employ girls
who are paid a small monthly salary and get most of their pay from
commissions on drinks customers buy them and from what are referred to
as barfines in Bangkok. A barfine is a fee paid to the bar that frees
the girl from working for the rest of the day and allows the girl to go
out with the customers. Sometimes customers take girls dancing and to
dinner but most of the time they take the girl home for sex. There are
quotas and girls who don't get barfined enough or induce enough men to
buy them drinks get their salary proportionately reduced.
It sounds worse than it is because the girls
are all over 20, are free to quit whenever they want, go home with
whomever they please, and, in the end, many actually end up marrying
and/or girlfriending men they meet at the bar. Legions of Thai girls
from poor, uneducated, impoverished backgrounds have found opportunity
and a better life by working in Bangkok bars and meeting foreign men
over the years.
The whole system sounds a bit unsavory to
Western sensibilities but the system is ubiquitous in Bangkok among
foreigners and native Thais and a form of the same system is prevalent
in most Asian countries–Communist China, Hong Kong, Japan, and Vietnam.
It is even rumored that the wives of several high Thai government
officials and politicians started out as a hostesses in similar clubs.
Before BigBabyKenny.com was turned off, you could have read through the
many posts on the site for more information. Now that BigBabyKenny.com
has been turned off, I'm not sure if an equivalent source exists.
The articles were too good at laying bare the
economic underpinnings, the inter-personal dynamics, the nuts and bolts,
and even the humorous side of The Thailand Girl Scene.
The discussion of The Thailand Girl Scene was
too interesting and too revealing about the realities of life in a third
world country where the usual ways women advance themselves socially and
economically in The World are blocked off.
The photography was too good at documenting the
nitty gritty nature of the various nooks and crannies of the Thailand
nightlife industry.
The realities of life, love, dating, marriage,
and sex in Southeast Asia and the politically correct western centric
view of the world clashed.
Better to live in a make believe fairy tale
western fantasy version of Southeast Asian culture and society than deal
with an accurate, well documented truth.
Unfortunately, because I am a professor at a
big public university, the popularity and publicity surrounding the
ideas, the subjects and questions discussed and debated, and, of course,
the ground breaking photography at BigBabyKenny.com became so great that
the site had to be turned off.
Read the full
article
University Statement
See
article from
bigbabykenny.com
Some of you may be aware of an issue that recently
has received some attention related to a website run by a university
employee on his own personal time with no connection to Cal State
Northridge. I am writing with an update about this issue.
Professor Kenneth Ng informed me Thursday night
that he is reluctantly taking down his web site on Friday. He will
replace it with a brief account of the business dispute that led to the
current controversy.
Professor Ng said that he is taking down the
site because of the deleterious effect it had on the university's
reputation, not because he considered the subject matter and content as
unsuitable for public discourse, public discussion, or public debate.
I thank him for his reflection and removal of
the site. I thank the University community for their comments.
I understand that some people will be
disappointed that we did not force the site's closure; others already
object that university leadership was critical of a university
employee's speech.
We are trying to balance two principles that,
in this case, clashed. Our commitment to gender equity compels us to see
the site as offensive; our commitment to expression urges us to tolerate
words and pictures we find intolerant. As university leaders, we believe
open debate is critical to ordering our values and determining our acts.
While belief in an absolute right to censor might initially comfort us;
our and us has a way of quickly narrowing to you
and me. Then the danger is that exclusion and exploitation, the
acts that initially incited us to censor, become the rules of the day.
As with other incidents that have arisen on
campus in the past, I encourage everyone to use the issues that have
been raised in this matter as an opportunity to examine and talk about
how we deal with values and perspectives that may conflict with our own
while balancing the rights of others.
Harry Hellenbrand, Provost